However, we agree that choosing a stockbroker should be entirely dependent on what kind of requirements you have. Nonetheless, it is still good to know what other options you have to choose from. 5Paisa vs Ventura Securities capital brokerage compare will help you further.
This post will present to you a throat to throat comparison of 5paisa and Ventura Securities.
This comparative study will give you a better idea about the working of the two brokers, and can you further go ahead to decide which one shall you go for.
The similarities, as well as the differences between the two, will be more effectively highlighted in the below comparison.
The comparison is based on more than a hundred attributes that highly vary in degree and angle. Here is a list of the metrics based on which we have compared the two stockbrokers:
Overview
Customer support
Demat account
Brokerage charges & fees
Customer rating
Services
Research advisory
Products
Trading platform
Offers
Exposure / leverage
Other charges
Let us get to the comparisons.
5Paisa Vs Ventura Securities
| Basis | 5Paisa | Ventura Securities |
| About the Broker | 5Paisa comes second on the list of the best discount brokers throughout our country. Having its base in Mumbai, 5Paisa is a tributary of the India Infoline group. Though established in the 20th century, it was re-established with newer plans and models to become an online retain broker. | Ventura Securities Ltd. is a popular stock broker of India which was incorporated in Mumbai in 1994. Ventura is known for the wide range of services and products it provides with the aid of over 500 business partners and 25 branches which are located across 300 Indian cities. It is a full service broker that provides advisory services to domestic as well as foreign institutions, retail investors, and high net worth. Ventura is famous for its domain knowledge and strength in the thriving derivatives market of India. |
| Type of broker | Discount Broker | Full service broker |
| Supported Exchange | BSE, NSE, MCX-SX | MCX, NSE, BSE |
| Plan Type | Flat rate Plan | Plan 3500 |
| Year of Incorporation | 2015 | 1994 |
| Number of Branches in India | 900 | 35 |
5Paisa and Ventura Securities Charges
There a vast difference between the charges kept by the two stock brokers. While 5Paisa charges Rs. 650 as the opening fee for trading account, Ventura Securities charges only Rs. 150. However, Ventura Securities charges Rs. 300 for demat account opening while 5Paisa does it for free.
| Basis | 5Paisa | Ventura Securities |
| Trading Account AMC | Free | NIL |
| Demat Account Opening Fees | free | Rs. 300 |
| Demat Account AMC | Rs. 400 | Rs. 400 |
| Demat Account Status | Not Mandatory | Not Mandatory |
| Trading Account Opening Fees | Rs. 650 | Rs. 150 |
5Paisa Vs Ventura Securities Brokerage
While 5paisa charges a flat rate of Rs 10 per executed order, pay plans of Ventura Securities is a little more complicated than that. Ventura Securities has 3 prepaid plans namely Plan 3500, Plan 18000, and Plan 72000. Each of these plans by Ventura Securities has distinct percent charges as well as different fixed pay per executed order.
Brokerage Plan 1
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Flat Rate Plan | Plan 3500 | |
| Equity Delivery | Rs. 10 per performed order | 0.20% |
| Equity Futures | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.03% |
| Equity Intraday | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.03% |
| Equity Options | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees50 per order |
| Currency Options Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees20 per order |
| Currency Futures Trading | Rupees 10 per performed order | Rupees 20 per order |
| Commodity Futures Trading | Rupees 10 per performed order | |
| Fixed Charges | NA | |
| Commodity Options Trading | Rupees 10 per performed order |
Brokerage Plan 2
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Flat Rate Plan | Plan 18000 | |
| Equity Delivery | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.15% |
| Fixed Charges | NA | Rs. 18000 per year |
| Equity Intraday | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.15% |
| Commodity Options Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | |
| Equity Options | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees35 per order |
| Equity Futures | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.15% |
| Currency Futures Trading | Rupees 10 per performed order | Rupees 20 per order |
| Commodity Futures Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | |
| Currency Options Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees20 per order |
Brokerage Plan 3
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Flat Rate Plan | Plan 72000 | |
| Equity Delivery | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.10% |
| Fixed Charges | NA | Rupees72000 per year |
| Equity Intraday | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.01% |
| Equity Options | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees18 per order |
| Equity Futures | Rupees10 per performed order | 0.01% |
| Currency Futures Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees20 per order |
| Commodity Futures Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | |
| Currency Options Trading | Rupees10 per performed order | Rupees20 per order |
| Commodity Options Trading | Rupees10 per performed order |
Other Charges
| Other Brokerage Charges | ||
| Minimum Brokerage Charges | Rupees10 per trade | Delivery – 2p per share; Intraday – 1p per share |
| Call & Trade Charges | Rupees100 per call (irrespective of the number of calls) | NIL |
5Paisa or Ventura Securities Transaction Charges
This table compares 5Paisa and Ventura Securities on PCM fee and transaction charges by segment.
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Equity Intraday | 0.00325% | 0.0038% |
| Equity Delivery | 0.00325% | 0.0038% |
| Equity Futures | 0.0021% | 0.0027% |
| Currency Futures | 0.0021% | |
| Equity Options | 0.051% (on premium) | 0.75% on premium) |
| Commodity | 0.0025% | |
| Currency Options | 0.051% |
5Paisa vs Ventura Securities Exposure Margin
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Equity Intraday Margin | Up to 20x | Up to 5x |
| Equity Delivery Margin | Up to 4x (Category E 4x, A 3.5x, B 3x, C 2x, D 1.5x) | 2x with 24% interest per year |
| Equity Futures Margin | Intra-day: 3.5x | Carry forward: 1x (no margin) | 3x |
| Currency Futures Margin | Intra-day: 1 time | Carry forward: 1x | Up to 2x |
| Equity Options Margin | Intra-day: 1x | Carry forward: 1x | NIL |
| Currency Options Margin | Intra-day: 1x | Carry forward: 1x | NA |
| Commodity Options | ||
| Commodity Futures Margin | 3x |
5Paisa vs Ventura Securities Feature Comparison
Both these brokers, 5Paisa and Ventura Securitiesoffer 2 in 1 account which includes demat and trading account. None of the two brokers offer automated trading.
Margin funding is not offered by Ventura Securitieswhereas it is offered by 5Paisa. None of the above mentioned two share brokers offer NRI trading facility.
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Charting | YES | YES |
| 3 in 1 account | NA | NA |
| Automated Trading | NA | NA |
| Online Demo | YES | YES |
| SMS Alerts | YES | |
| Online Portfolio | YES | YES |
| Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash) | YES | |
| Margin Trading Funding Availability | YES | |
| Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O) | YES | |
| Intraday Square-Off Time | 3:10 PM | |
| Trading Platform | 5Paisa Trade Station | Pointer, Web |
| Other Features | Fundamental data available on chart |
5Paisa vsVentura Securities Investment Options
Both 5Paisa and Ventura Securities offer investment and trading options in equity derivatives and equity on exchanges of both BSE and NSE.
Both stock brokers offer trading options in MCX commodity. Both the stock brokers offers the facility of dealing in currency, IPO, mutual funds, bonds, and debt. None of the brokers have PMS Service.
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Commodity | NA | YES |
| Stock / Equity | YES | YES |
| Currency | YES | YES |
| Mutual Funds | YES | YES |
| Initial Public Offers (IPO) | YES | YES |
| Bond / NCD | YES | YES |
| Other Investment Options | Mutual Funds, Insurance | |
| Debt | YES | YES |
5Paisa vs Ventura Securities Order Type Offered
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Cover Order | YES | NA |
| Bracket Order | YES | NA |
| BTST (Buy Today Sell Tomorrow) | YES | NA |
| AMO (After Market Order) | YES | NA |
| STBT (Sell Today Buy Tomorrow) | YES | NA |
| GTC (Good Till Cancelled) | NA | NA |
5Paisa vs Ventura Securities Research Report
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Free Tips | NA | YES |
| Daily Market Report | NA | YES |
| News Alerts | NA | YES |
| Quarterly Result Analysis | NA | YES |
5Paisa vs Ventura Securities suitable for which investor type
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Trader | YES | YES |
| Active Investor | YES | YES |
| Casual Investor |
5Paisa vs. Ventura Securities Customer Services
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Online live chat | NA | YES |
| 24 * 7 customer service | NA | NA |
| Through branches | NA | YES |
5paisa Vs Ventura Securities Advantages and Disadvantages
Each of the two share brokers have their own advantages as well as disadvantages that they tag along. While 5Paisa is a discount broker, Ventura Securities is a full broker. There are multiple points of advantages and disadvantages which are written not in a comparative manner but a matter-of-factly manner.
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Advantages | · 5Paisa offers brokerage services at extremely cheap rates. Only Rupees 10. · The brokerage fee is flat. You do not have to worry about the size of the trade. · Free access to trading software such as trading 5paisa terminal and 5paisa mobile app. · You get up to 4 times more coverage in (EDT) equity delivery trading. · You get up to 20 times more coverage in (EIT) equity intraday trading. · You get almost 3.5 times more coverage in (DIT) derivatives intraday trading. · It is backed by India Infoline. It is a leading non-banking financial institution having experience of over twenty years. | · Ventura Securities give you the option of paying Rs. 1.20lacs as the margin currency when opening an account. Thus, making brokerage negotiable. The amount can also be withdrawn after the account has been opened. · Ventura securities offers an AMC free demat account for lifetime. · It is also a depository participant of the NSDL or National Securities Depository Limited. · A wide range of financial products such as Corporate FDs, bonds, mutual funds, currency, commodities, and equities are available. · Investment plans in mutual funds and equity are available for Foreign Investors (FIs), Person of Indian Origins (PIOs), and Non Resident Indians (NRIs) with the aid of a devoted NRI service cell. · The facility of online fund transfer is available through multiple major banks including IDBI, Bank of Baroda, Axis, SBI, ICICI, HDFC, and others. · It has branches in all the major cities of India. · You can view your live stock quotes on your mobile phone. |
| Disadvantages | · Rs 100 is charges for every call excluding the brokerage charges. Traders can place unlimited number of calls at once. · An additional cost has to be paid to get access to advisory and research. · As opposed to other well-known stock brokers, a higher exchange turnover cost is charged by 5Paisa. · Rs 25 for every demat transaction are charged. · 5Paisa does not offer demat and trading NRI account. · Commodity trading facility is not available at 5paisa.com. · Only a 2 in 1 account is available, while some other stockbrokers offer 3 in 1 accounts also. | · Ventura Securities offers only prepaid plans. Thus, the option of paying afterwards in not available. · The company does not provide banking services. Thus, it only offers a 2 in 1 account and not a 3 in 1 account. |
5Paisa vs Ventura Securities Ratings
| 5Paisa | Ventura Securities | |
| Fees rating | 3.5 / 5 | 3.5 / 5 |
| Trading brokerage rating | 3.5 / 5 | 3.5 / 5 |
| Trading platform usability | 2.5 / 5 | 3.5 / 5 |
| Customer service rating | 2.5 / 5 | 3.5 / 5 |
| Overall rating | 2.5 / 5 | 3.5 / 5 |
| Broker rating | 2.8 / 5 | 3.6 / 5 |
Conclusion
After having read the above written comparison of 5Paisa vs Ventura Securities, the two superbly well-known stock brokers, it is up to you whether you decide to go with 5Paisa or with Ventura Securities.
Each of them is equipped with they own set of pros and cons. Select the broker based on what kind of services and products you are looking for and which suits you best.
This post about 5Paisa vs Venture Securities comparison is to help you pin which is a better option for your trading needs.
