angel broking

5Paisa Vs India Bulls Venture (Subh) – Logical Assessment

angel broking

5Paisa Vs India Bulls (Subh) – Comparison

Both of these are two broking companies of share market. They are providing trading related services to the traders. To choose one of them, a clear comparison of 5Paisa vs Indiabulls (Subh) is here.

5Paisa started its journey from Mumbai as a discount broker in 2016. It is a part of the IIFL (India Infoline Finance Ltd) family. 

Also, it charges brokerage INR.10/- per trade – which is the lowest recorded brokerage charge to date in India. 

India Bulls (Subh) is a famous discount broker for offering very low brokerage plans to customers. 

It offers an unlimited trading plan, free trading platform, free call & trade facility, free research report & zero interest marginal funding. 

It has a base with more than 7 lakhs customer, 900 sub-broker and presence in 18+ cities of India.                             

5 Notable Features: 

5Paisa:

  1. Enables Instant paperless account opening with Aadhaar. 
  2. In association with various insurance companies offers different insurance to the customer as an investment option.  
  3. Margin funding facility @18% p.a. interest.
  4. The robotic advisory platform for the investor for a customized experience. 
  5. Flat INR. 10/- brokerage for currency derivatives, Future, option & Equity cash. 
Related Post:   Zerodha Kite Vs. HDFC Securities Blink: Comparing Two Giant Trading Terminals in India

India Bulls (Subh): 

  1. No brokerage fee for trading in Equity, F&O, and Currency.
  2. Monthly fixed charges are there.
  3. No interest in Marginal trading.
  4. Paperless account opening. 
5Paisa vs. India Bulls Venture (Subh)

Comparison on Services: 

Here we are comparing 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) based on the facilities they offer. In terms of brokerage charge & customer service 5Paisa is in the forward position. Whereas, in terms of the investment offering India Bulls (subh) is leading.

 Particulars5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
Overall Rating★★★★★★★★
Rating on Brokerage Charges★★★★★★★
Rating on Trading Platform★★★★★★★★
Rating on Investments Offering★★★★★★★★★
Rating on Customer Service★★★★★★★
Broker Type Discount BrokerDiscount Broker
Exchanges Supported BSE, NSEBSE, NSE, MCX, NCDEX

5Paisa vs. India Bulls Venture on AOC & AMC: 

Both 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) provide a free DEMAT account & trading AMC to its customers. Based on the AMC & Account opening charges we can compare 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) as hereunder:

Particulars 5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
Trading Account Opening Fees650 Rupees (Free Now Promotion Offer)500 Rupees
Trading AMCFree of costFree of cost
DEMAT Account Opening FeesFree of costFree of cost
DEMAT AMC45 Rupees PM if Trade, else Zero450 Rupees PA (2nd Year Onward)
Provide DP Service

Comparison on Brokerage Plan: 

Here we have compared 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) based on brokerage plan offerings to the customers. Only India Bulls (Subh) has multiple types of brokerage plan options. Whereas, 5Paisa doesn’t have any kind of brokerage plan offering. 

Related Post:   Discount Broker vs Full-Service Broker in India - A Brief Comparison
Plan Types5paisa BrokerageIndiabulls Ventures Brokerage
Multiple Brokerage Plans🞬
Monthly Brokerage Plans🞬🞬
Yearly Brokerage Plans🞬🞬

Comparison on Brokerage Charge: 

5Paisa offers a flat fee-based brokerage plan offering INR.20/- each. Whereas, India Bulls (Subh) offers unlimited trading plans. Here we have compared India Bulls (Subh) & 5Paisa based on brokerage charge offering. Both brokers don’t have any minimum brokerage charges.

Particulars5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
Plan NameFlat Fee 20 Rupees Trading PlanUnlimited trading plan
Equity DeliveryFlat Fee 20 Rupees1000 Rupees
Equity IntradayFlat Fee 20 RupeesInclude in Delivery
Equity FuturesFlat Fee 20 Rupees1000 Rupees
Equity OptionsFlat Fee 20 RupeesInclude in Derivatives
Currency FuturesFlat Fee 20 RupeesInclude in Derivatives
Currency OptionsFlat Fee 20 RupeesInclude in Derivatives
Commodity TradingFlat Fee 20 RupeesNA
Minimum BrokerageNANIL
Hidden ChargesNoInfo Not Available
FundingYes – 18% interest PAInfo Not Available
Call & Trade Charges100 Rupees per call(No limit of orders)15 Rupees per executed order

Comparison on Transaction Charge:

In this below-mentioned chart, the details of transactional charges are mentioned according to the product type. We can see that the transactional charges of Indiabulls (Subh) are higher than 5Paisa in certain segments:

Particulars5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
Equity Delivery325 Rupees Per Cr325 Rupees Per Cr
Equity Intraday325 Rupees Per Cr325 Rupees Per Cr
Equity Futures190 Rupees Per Cr250 Rupees Per Cr
Equity Options5000 Rupees Per Cr5500 Rupees Per Cr
Currency Futures110 Rupees Per Cr120 Rupees Per Cr
Currency Options4000 Rupees Per Cr4500 Rupees Per Cr
CommodityNANon-Agri: 300 Rupees Per Cr
Agri: 250 Rupees Per Cr

Comparison on Account Feature: 

Both 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) provide various facilities to their customers. All the facilities hereby mentioned below along with the comparison:

Related Post:   Stoxkart Vs ICICI Direct: A Comparison Between The Leading Stock Broking Services In The Indian Scenario
Particulars5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
3 in 1 Account🞬🞬
Charting
Algo Trading🞬
SMS Alerts
Online Demo🞬
Online Portfolio🞬
Margin Trading Funding Available
Combined Ledger for Equity and Commodity
Intraday Square-off Time3:15 PM3:15 PM
NRI Trading🞬
Other FeaturesNILMobile Application:
Power Indiabulls Mobile

5Paisa vs. India Bulls Venture on Trading Medium: 

Both 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) offers different platforms for trading to their customers- like, online, mobile, desktop, tablet, etc. The comparison based on that is given below:

Particulars5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
Desktop Trading Platform5paisaTradeStationPower Indiabulls
Desktop Platform (Windows)
Desktop Platform (Mac)🞬
Web Trading Platform
Web Trading Detailhttps://www.5paisa.com/online-tradinghttps://shubhtrade.indiabulls.com
Mobile Site
Mobile Trading
Mobile Trading App5paisa Mobile AppIndiabulls Shubh
Android Mobile App
iPhone Mobile App (IOS)
Android Tablet App
iPad App (IOS)
Trading Software ChargesFreeInfo Not Available

Comparison on Investment Products: 

According to the large variety of investment opportunities, both 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) provide many options like Mutual fund, bond, Insurance, SIP, IPO, etc. The comparison is mentioned as follows:

Particulars5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
Equity Cash and F&O
Currency Derivatives
Commodity
Online IPO Application🞬🞬
Mutual Funds
Bond / NCD
ETF
Banking🞬🞬
Insurance
Forex🞬🞬
MF SIP Investment
Equity SIP Investment🞬🞬
PMS Service🞬🞬
Other Investment OptionsNILNIL

Comparison on Margin /Leverage: 

Considering the leverage we here have compared 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) as below:

Particulars5paisa MarginIndiabulls Ventures Margin
Equity Delivery Margin Maximum 3.5x via Margin Funding system.Info Not Available
Equity Intraday Margin Maximum 10x or 10% subject to Variable and ELM.Maximum 10x or 10% subject to Variable and ELM.
Futures Margin 1x or the particular SPAN + Margin.1x or the particular SPAN + Margin.
Options Margin 1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure in Selling a share and Premium Margin in Buying a share.1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure in Selling a share and Premium Margin in Buying a share.
Equity CO Margin Maximum 10x or 10% subject to Variable and ELM, no further Margin charges are included for Cover Order.Maximum 10x or 10% subject to Variable and ELM, no further Margin charges are included for Cover Order.
Futures CO Margin 1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure margin, no further Margin charges are included for Futures Cover Order.1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure margin, no further Margin charges are included for Futures Cover Order.
Options CO Margin 1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure margin (Selling a share) or Premium Margin (Buying a share), no further Margin charges are included for Options Cover Order.1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure margin (Selling a share) or Premium Margin (Buying a share), no further Margin charges are included for Options Cover Order.
Commodity Margin 1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure in Selling a share and Premium Margin in Buying a share.1x or the particular SPAN + Exposure in Selling a share and Premium Margin in Buying a share.

Comparison on Customer Support: 

Here are the comparison & details of 5Paisa vs. India Bulls (Subh) regarding customer assistance:

Particulars 5paisaIndiabulls Ventures
24/7 Customer Service 🞬🞬
Email Support 
Online Live Chat 🞬🞬
Phone Support 
Toll-Free Number 🞬🞬
Through Branches 🞬
Customer Care Number “+91 89766 89766”Info Not Available
Account Opening Process Online/PaperlessInfo Not Available
Customer Support Email [email protected]Info Not Available
Knowledge Centre/Education https://www.5paisa.com/knowledge-centreInfo Not Available
Head Office Address 5paisa headquarter
Sun Infotech Park, Road No.
16V, Plot No.B-23 Thane
Industrial Area, Wagle Estate,
Thane – 400604
Info Not Available
Website https://www.5paisa.com/Info Not Available
open India Bulls Venture demat account

Comparison on DEMAT Account Feature: 

Here we will compare 5Paisa vs. India Bulls (Subh) based on offering DEMAT A/c to its customers for share trading. The facilities & charges related to DEMAT account is compared below:

 Particulars5paisaIndia bulls Ventures
DP SourceCDSLCDSL
DP ID 82500No
DEMAT Account Annual Maintenance Charges(AMC)Monthly Plan – INR.45 (In case of any transaction in a month)Holdings up to INR.50,000 – Nil
Holdings between INR.50,001 to INR.2,00,000 – INR.100
Advance DepositNilNil
Statutory chargesNilNil
Transaction Charges on Debit (Per ISIN)0.025% or INR.25 whichever is higher + CDSL charges0.02% of the transaction value or INR.20 whichever is higher + INR.5.50 (CDSL Charges)
DEMATINR.15 per certificateINR.5 per certificate (Min INR.50 per request)
REMATINR.15 for every hundred securities or INR.15 per certificate whichever is higherINR.35 for every hundred securities
Pledge CreationINR.500.02% of the transaction value or INR.35 whichever is higher
Pledge Creation ConfirmationNIL0.02% of the transaction value or INR.35 whichever is higher
Pledge ClosureNIL0.02% of the transaction value or INR.35 whichever is higher
Pledge Closure ConfirmationNIL0.02% of the transaction value or INR.35 whichever is higher
Pledge InvocationNIL0.02% of the transaction value or INR.35 whichever is higher
Failed Instruction ChargesNilNil
Other ChargesNilNil
open 5 paisa demat account

Conclusion: 

We hereby compared 5Paisa vs India Bulls (Subh) in this study but there are numerous points where 5Paisa & India Bulls (Subh) performed similarly. Both are old market competitors and already having a huge customer base. But it should be kept in mind that the requirement of individual investor change due to many factors. So, whatever the rating is there, an investor should decide based on his/her requirement only.

angel broking